meneldil's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[Wheatember]

Ok...

Good stuff:
That motif on the guitar is really nice, and I like the sound of clean guitar with reverb.

Bad stuff:
It's repetitive as hell, as I said in the forums - there's completely no feeling to it!

MAKE SOMETHING HAPPEN!

Reminds me of one album by Placebo I listened to - ain't that bad, but... every track is the same. Same goes for this.

I understand you want vocals to be an instrument nicely mixed with other instruments, but they still don't need to be so damn monotone. It could be a loop of like two bars and it would be the same. Well, that bridge doesn't do that much anyway.

Sorry for the bad score, but I'm trying to be honest.

Good luck with new tracks tho;)

[Snap Yo Fingers -LOOP-]

OMGWTFROFLCOPTERLOLLERCOASTER OMG IT'S TEH TOPIC!

Nice one, tho repetitive.

Father-of-Death responds:

Hahaha thanks man! ^^

[Lion King]

Made my day

Beatiful harmony, smooth, catchy melody, and, what's most important, great lyrics!

Havn't laughed so much since I saw OCON had done some crappy 2-second loop with crappy drums, called it "Paragon9x - Chaoz Devotion 2" and got diamond track with insane number of downloads xD

[Endless Handbag Redesign]

Nice

I like it, it's quite diverse, sounds clear and composition overally is nice;) Tho it's a bit simple, could use more complexity and be a bit more interesting.

Still, I like it.

I made a celebration track as well xD

[MegaMan2-Drwilly's theme-MJ]

Yeah

Heavy, juicy, overdriven guitars, but also some melody... that's the best thing in the world. I love that sound.

Perfect.

5 of course.

[The Beautiful Savage]

Great!

I love it!

Reverb adds to the feeling awesomely, everything is mixed perfectly. Also, instruments sound very realistic, though overall quality is not perfect (well, I don't really care).

The most important thing is you're great composer;)

MilkMan-Dan responds:

I suppose that is the most important thing... and the imperfection comes from the fact that every note you hear is crafted by hand on my keyboard... so if I slip up even in the slightest you'll hear it.

Thanks for the review mate.

MMD

[Crashing Machines]

Sounds interesting

Original, nice, ambient track. I think of some mysterious game when i hear it, it definitely could be utilized in flash portal;)

It's a bit empty at some points, but I guess that was on purpose to add some feeling to it.

I liked it;)

[IRVGM - MMBN4 Boss Battle!]

Perfect for gba games ;)

Is it just as it was in the original track, or is it changed? If it's changed, then you're very good composer and I commend you:o

What did you use to get that 8-bit feeling?

IRedoVideoGameMusic responds:

Squares.

This is the original track.

[My Mind]

Sounds nice

Instruments together sound nice, though in some moments i could hear that pad or whatever it is in background is definitely looped badly:/ You should've picked another soundfont.

Other than that, it was pleasant, peaceful, though it lacked diversity.

Cosmos8942 responds:

Hmm, I just listened to the song three times...and I didn't hear anything that would make the audio sound as it did to you...=.=...I dunno...maybe I am missing something, sure you weren't listening to something else while you listened to this? XP. But yeah...I have to trust those that listen to a song that I remixed...probably just sounded right to me cause I made it.

Otherwise thanks for the review. Now if I can just get FL Studio to work again T.T.

-AJ-

[Hippy Hop]

Pretty interesting

I quite like it, it has a difference, and originality is definitely important to me;)

Scratching was very good. The only thing is it contrasted with background music, but well... it's not an instrument that can be in tune;) It's only at the beginning, then it gets interesting and scratching goes well together with the beat.

Well, 5 for experimenting =]

LfunkeyA responds:

thnx! i got a criticism about the scratching from a friend too, will try to fix that next time i use scratching samples extensively.